Name: Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Start: 2024-04-04
End: 2024-08-31
Location: Criterion Theatre

London

London Nav Links [NEW]

More shows

WL UK Nav

[timeout] Desktop Logo

Time Out

WL Terms

Terms and conditions

WL Privacy policy

Privacy policy

UK WL Musicals

Musicals

UK WL Plays

Plays

UK WL Family Theatre

Family

UK WL Deals & Special Offers

Special Offers

UK WL All Shows

All Shows

WL - All Attraction - LON

All Attractions

WL UK Info Links

INFO

WL FAQs

Help and Support

WL UK Help Links

HELP

WL UK Footer

Digital Partners

News & Media

UK WL Ballet & Opera

Ballet & Opera

WL Nav with Ballet & Opera

GWR Button Logo 01

GWR Nav Link to GWR site

Buy train tickets

WL Nav - GWR

WL Nav - The Times

WL Nav - Attractions Included

null

Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) - LON [38626]

Two Strangers header - LON

Explore West End shows, book last minute theatre tickets, and more

Discover London

LON | TT | App Carousel | The Merchant of Venice | 41659 | 24hr Offer

The Merchant of Venice 1936 - LON [41659] 

The Merchant of Venice 1936

Tensions in London’s East End are rising and Shylock, a resilient single mother and hard-working businesswoman, is desperate to protect her daughter’s future. When the charismatic merchant Antonio comes to her for a loan, a high-stakes deal is struck. Will Shylock take her revenge, and who will pay the ultimate price?

LON | TT | App Carousel | My Master Builder | 43486 | Onsale

Children under the age of 16 must be accompanied by and sat next to an adult ticketholder (18+). Children under the age of 3 will not be admitted.

My Master Builder - LON [43486]

My Master Builder

Ewan McGregor returns to the London stage, reuniting with director Michael Grandage, to lead the company of Lila Raicek’s new play My Master Builder.

Book now

LON | TT | App Carousel | Back to the Future | 22396 | Media

Back to the Future - App Carousel - LON

LON | TT | App Carousel | Hercules | 43135 

Hercules - Set Alerts - App Carousel - LON

Ages 6+. Children under 4 (including babies in arms) will not be admitted into the theatre. All persons aged 16 or under must be accompanied by an adult 18+ & may not sit on their own. All persons must have a ticket.

Disney's Hercules - LON [43135]

Disney's Hercules

Ancient Greece. A time of gods, mortals… and Hercules, who doesn't quite belong to either. But if he's not a god, how can he possibly save the world from Hades? It's one thing flexing those pecs, but going from zero to hero requires a different kind of strength. 

LON | TT | App Carousel | Harry Potter and the Cursed Child | Media

Production shot of Harry Potter And The Cursed Child: Both Parts in London, showing students cheer enthusiastically.

[Media #1] Parts One and Two 21176

LON | TT | App Carousel | Strictly Come Dancing Tour 2025 | Media

LON | TT | App Carousel | Clueless | 36641 | Media

LON | TT | App Carousel | Clueless | 36641 | Onsale

LON | TT | Young Vic | App Tile

[WT App Link] - LON - Young Vic 2024

View all shows

Young Vic 2024 Season

LON | TT | Park Theatre | App Tile

[WT App Link] - LON - Park Theatre

Park Theatre

LON | TT | London Attractions | App Tile

[WT App Link] - LON - London Attractions

Now on TodayTix

London Attractions

LON | TT | English National Opera | App Tile

[WT App Link] - LON - English National Opera

English National Opera

LON | TT | Bush Theatre | App Tile

[WT App Link] - LON - Bush Theatre

Bush Theatre

LON | TT | Royal Ballet and Opera | App Webtile

[WT App Link] - LON - Royal Ballet and Opera

Royal Ballet and Opera

LON | TT | Royal Court Season | App Tile 

[WT App Link] - LON - Royal Court Theatre

Royal Court Theatre

LON | TT | Kiln Theatre | App Tile

[WT App Link] - LON -Kiln Theatre

Kiln Theatre

LON | TT | The Globe | App Tile 

[WT App Link] - LON - The Globe

Shakespeare's Globe

LON | TT | Lyric Hammersmith | App Tile 

[WT App Link] - LON - Lyric Hammersmith

Lyric Hammersmith

LON | TT | Strictly Come Dancing The Live Tour

Strictly Come Dancing The Live Tour - App Tile 

Strictly Come Dancing The Live Tour

LON | TT | App Home Tile | Musicals Candlelight

Ages 6+. Under 16s must be accompanied by an adult.

Musicals by Candlelight - LON [25037]

Musicals by Candlelight

Discover your favourite musicals like never before!

LON | TT | App Home Tile | Christmas by Candlelight

Christmas by Candlelight

Musicals by Candlelight at Christmas

The Devil Wears Prada LON

Ages 12+ (recommended). Under 5s cannot be admitted to the theatre. Guests 15 and under must be accompanied by an adult. All patrons, regardless of age, must have a valid ticket.

The Devil Wears Prada - LON [34706]

The Devil Wears Prada

As London Fashion Week descends on the Capital, the catwalk is out for the launch of The Devil Wears Prada, a new musical, based on the blockbuster film and bestselling novel, that will strut into London’s Dominion Theatre in October 2024.

LON | TT | App Tile | Stranger Things | 29263 | 

Ages 12+ (recommended). Under 16s must be accompanied by an adult. Under 5s not permitted.

Stranger Things: The First Shadow - LON [29263]

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

Brought to life by a multi-award-winning creative team, who take theatrical storytelling and stagecraft to a whole new dimension, this gripping new adventure will take you right back to the beginning of the Stranger Things story – and may hold the key to the end.


LON | TT | App Home Tile | Moulin Rouge! The Musical | 23350 | Media

Moulin Rouge! The Musical - LON [23350] 

Moulin Rouge! The Musical

Enter a world of splendour and romance, of eye-popping excess, of glitz, grandeur, and glory! A world where Bohemians and aristocrats rub elbows and revel in electrifying enchantment. Pop the champagne and prepare for the spectacular spectacular… 

LON | TT | App Tile | Back to the Future | Ad Unit

Ages 6+. Under 16s must be accompanied by an adult (18+). Under 4s will not be admitted.

Back to the Future: The Musical - LON [22396]

Back to the Future: The Musical

When Marty McFly is transported back to 1955 in a time machine built by the eccentric scientist Doc Brown, he accidentally changes the course of history. Now he’s in a race against time to fix the past and send himself... back to the future.

LON | TT | App Home List Item | My Master Builder | 43486 | Onsale

LON | TT | App Home List Item | The MErchant of Venice 1936 | 41659 | 24hr Offer

LON | TT | App Tile | Harry Potter and the Cursed Child | Video Ad Unit

LON | TT | Video Tile | Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

TodayTix App Home - LON

Special offer - TT Genre - LON

Latest London Insider Posts

Venues in London

LON - Musicals - TodayTix

Musicals in London

LON - Family / Kid-friendly (TT)

Family shows

LON - Under £25

Tickets under £25

LON - Stars on Stage (TT)

Stars on Stage in London

LON - Opening soon

Opening Soon

LON - Plays - TodayTix

LON - All Attractions 

Attractions in the UK

LON - Off West End

All Off West End Shows

LON - All Shows (All Theatre Primary Categories) (TT) - Rush & Lottery

All shows in London

London All Shows Image

London Tile Image

London musicals

London plays

TT - Deals & Special Offers 

Offers

London family

London access

Rush & Lottery

TT - LON - Gift Guide

Gift Guide

More

Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)

Two Strangers - Poster

Two Strangers - Poster May24 - LON

Two Strangers - Square May24 - LON

Two Strangers - Hero May24 - LON

Two Strangers Media

Production Image of Two Strangers Carry A Cake (Across New York) in London, featuring Sam Tutty and Dujonna Gift

Two Strangers Lon - prod 3

Two Strangers Lon - prod 2

Two Strangers Lon - prod 1

A new British musical from writers Jim Barne and Kit Buchan.

Born in Crawley in 1998, Sam Tutty is currently starring in Jim Barne and Kit Buchan’s musical *[Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)](https://www.londontheatre.co.uk/show/38626-two-strangers-carry-a-cake-across-new-york)* at the Criterion Theatre in the West End.

He is best known for his West End debut as Evan in *[Dear Evan Hansen](https://www.londontheatre.co.uk/show/15595-dear-evan-hansen)*. He originated the role in London, following in the footsteps of Ben Platt who originated the character of Evan Hansen on Broadway.

Tutty spent the first decade of his life in West Sussex, before moving north to Hull. He later returned down south and attended Imberhorne Secondary School, whose alumni include 9 to 5 star Louise Redknapp. During his school years, he appeared in a number of productions including The Wizard of Oz.

After compulsory schooling, Tutty trained at Italia Conti Academy of Theatre Arts, later making his off-West End debut as Daniel in Once on this Island. His performance at Southwark Playhouse was widely praised, and a career in the West End looked promising. Tutty was originally cast as the alternate Evan for Dear Evan Hansen, however he was later promoted to the titular character.

His first performance as Evan was on 9 October 2019, ahead of an official opening night on 19 November 2019. In a review for LondonTheatre.co.uk, Mark Shenton said: “Tutty is another discovery, who pulls off the rare trick of projecting adolescent angst and insecurity with paradoxically confident ease. With his strawberry blonde hair and slight physical bearing, he embodies a nerdy character… There's a truthfulness to his acting - and a robust singing voice - that makes him feel utterly authentic and intensely moving.” In 2020, Tutty won an Olivier for Best Actor in a Musical.

Sam Tutty - LON

Recommended for ages 12+; This production contains some adult themes, including discussions of suicide. Children under the age of four will not be permitted in the theatre.

Entry Requirements - DMT

Dear Evan Hansen [15595] - LON

Dear Evan Hansen

Dear Evan Hansen [15595] - LON Product Media

<a href="/show/everybodys-talking-about-jamie">Everybody's Talking About Jamie</a> has just celebrated its 2nd birthday in the West End, a joyous musical about a British teenager embracing and asserting his gay drag identity at a Sheffield school at which he defiantly and unapologetically decides to go to his end of year prom in a dress. But now everybody will also be talking about <a href="/show/dear-evan-hansen">Evan Hansen</a>, another teenager at the centre of a musical, but this one's American and far more emotionally insecure.If <a href="/show/everybodys-talking-about-jamie">Jamie</a>, as both a show and a character, has a refreshing openness of spirit and blissfully defiant lack of apology, <a href="/show/dear-evan-hansen">Dear Evan Hansen</a> has a more earnest sincerity that may be initially cloying to British appetites, as it follows its title character who finds himself, unwittingly at first but then in a scheme that rapidly accelerates out of control, heralded as the best friend of a passing acquaintance at school who has committed suicide. He finds himself trapped in a lie, told initially with the good intention of comforting the boy's bereaved parents, but which soon takes on a life of its own as he needs to produce evidence of their relationship and a memorial campaign in honour of the lost schoolmate is launched.But if it feels a bit manipulative in more ways than one, that may be entirely intentional: it also dares to tackle the subject of teenage suicide head-on, and how the victim's classmates both manipulate and are manipulated by social media to their own ends. What is apparently healing becomes unwittingly sinister.It's not just a musical for the social media age but also puts its alternately productive and pernicious effects on full display.&nbsp; As such, it could not be more welcome.&nbsp; #YouWillBeFound is the hashtag behind the promotion of mental health awareness in the show, and the show itself is now finally to be found in the West End, three years after its 2016 Broadway premiere that saw the show win the 2017 Tony Award for Best Musical (along with five other wins) and where it is still running.In the stunningly slick and sleek production that has arrived at the <a href="/theatres/noel-coward-theatre">Noel Coward Theatre</a>, the show has also found and will make a new star of recent Italia Conti graduate Sam Tutty in the title role. Just as Jac Yarrow last summer graduated from ArtsEd to take the title role in <a href="/show/joseph-and-the-amazing-technicolor-dreamcoat">Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat</a> at the London Palladium (and who has now been announced will reprise it next summer), Tutty is another discovery, who pulls off the rare trick of projecting adolescent angst and insecurity with paradoxically confident ease. With his strawberry blonde hair and slight physical bearing, he embodies a nerdy character (far more successfully, in fact, that Ben Platt who originated the role on Broadway). There's a truthfulness to his acting - and a robust singing voice - that makes him feel utterly authentic and intensely moving.There's lovely complementary work from Rebecca McKinnis as his struggling single mother, with Lauren Ward, Rupert Young and Lucy Anderson as the parents and sister of Connor Murphy, the boy who has committed suicide. As in Next to Normal (also coincidentally directed by Michael Greif), the 2009 Broadway musical still unseen over here, that deceased son has a continuing dominant presence here; as played by Doug Colling, he has a haunting effect in every sense. There are also suitably obnoxious contributions from Jack Loxton and Nicole Raquel Dennis as Evan's classmates who play key roles in assisting him and promoting the campaign.Benj Pasek and Justin Paul's beautiful score may be a little ballad-heavy, but has integrity and depth that matches the story they have to tell, whose book is written by Steven Levenson. An onstage band, on the upper level of the set stage right, under the musical direction of Matt Smith, provides sumptuous accompaniment; there's particularly fine guitar playing from Tom Coppin and Mark Wraith.Just recently Florian Zeller's <a href="/show/the-son">The Son</a> played just down the street at the <a href="/theatres/duke-of-yorks-theatre">Duke of York's</a> that offered another shattering account of a teen suicide; <a href="/show/dear-evan-hansen">Dear Evan Hansen</a> will reach an even bigger audience, and its impact will resonate, hopefully far beyond the theatre's walls.<a href="/show/dear-evan-hansen">Dear Evan Hansen</a>&nbsp;is booking at the&nbsp;<a href="/theatres/noel-coward-theatre">Noel Coward Theatre</a>&nbsp;until 2nd May.&nbsp;<a href="/show/dear-evan-hansen">Dear Evan Hansen tickets</a>&nbsp;are available now.&nbsp;

Review - Dear Evan Hansen at the Noel Coward Theatre

INCLUDING BEST NEW MUSICALDEAR EVAN HANSEN is “the most vital and important musical of a generation” (Daily Mail, Baz Bamigboye) with “a raw, relevant and exhilarating score” (BBC Radio London, Jonathan Phang) from the songwriters of The Greatest Showman and La La Land.

**Noël Coward Theatre** is a popular venue in the heart of London that continues to draw audiences with its excellent choice of productions. This theatre is a prominent part of London's cultural fabric and has been a part of the city's arts scene since its opening in 1903. Named after the renowned playwright, Noël Coward, it was formerly known as the Albery Theatre. The theatre has a remarkable capacity of 872 seats, offering a fascinating range of viewing experiences. The venue is well-known for its diverse productions, ranging from musicals to classic plays and modern dramas. Past productions include 'Half a Sixpence', 'The Vortex', and 'Deathtrap'. The Theatre's design is a delightful blend of tradition and modernity, mirroring the diverse array of productions it hosts. The richly decorated interior adds to the sensory experience, making viewing a performance here a complete theatrical event. 

 **How to Get There** 
 The theatre is located in St Martin's Lane, a short walk from Leicester Square and Covent Garden tube stations. This makes the venue quite easily accessible by public transportation. There are also numerous bus routes which stop nearby. For patrons driving to the venue, there is a car park nearby in Chinatown. The theatre also offers bicycle racks for those who prefer to cycle.

Noël Coward Theatre - LON

Noël Coward Theatre

The Noël Coward Theatre is a prominent London venue known for diverse theatrical productions; accessible via public transportation, parking, and cycle.

The Criterion Theatre is a gem of Victorian architecture located in the bustling heart of London, nestled within the world-famous Piccadilly Circus. Hidden away underground, this grand and storied venue brims with rich history and elegance. Built in 1874 by architect Thomas Verity, and designed in a striking Italian Renaissance style, the theatre seats 588 people across three levels. Notably, it is constructed predominantly from concrete, a characteristic unusual for its time. The theatre's magnificent gilded interior and treasured Criterion Bar sublimely enhance the overall patron experience.

Over the years, the Criterion Theatre has been the host to a variety of productions spanning several genres, including comedies, dramas, thrillers, musical concerts, and matinees. Its 'Criterion New Writing Programme' reflects its commitment towards nurturing potential playwrights and encouraging new work.

### How to Get There

The Criterion Theatre is conveniently served by several modes of public transportation. The nearest Tube station is Piccadilly Circus, served by the Piccadilly and Bakerloo lines, a mere two-minute walk away. Numerous bus routes run along Piccadilly, Regent Street, and Shaftesbury Avenue, making the venue easily accessible. However, due to its central location, parking is limited and it's advisable to use public transportation if possible. The venue is within London’s Congestion Charge Zone, and for those choosing to drive, nearby parking is available at Q Park Chinatown in Newport Place.

Criterion Theatre - LON

Criterion Theatre

The Criterion Theatre is a historic Victorian theatre in London's Piccadilly Circus, easily accessible by tube and bus services.

Born in Crawley in 1998, Sam Tutty is best known for his West End debut as Evan in Dear Evan Hansen. He originated the role in London, following in the footsteps of Ben Platt who originated the character of Evan Hansen on Broadway.

Sam Tutty - Stars on Stage | London Theatre

Sam Tutty - Stars on Stage - 200x200

Dujonna Gift is currently starring as New Yorker Robin in Jim Barne and Kit Buchan’s new British musical *[Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)](https://www.londontheatre.co.uk/show/38626-two-strangers-carry-a-cake-across-new-york)* at the Criterion Theatre in the West End.

Gift has starred in a number of hit West End musicals, including *Dear Evan Hansen, Caroline, Or Change, Motown: The Musical*, and *Hamilton*. 

She is set to appear as Maple in the live-action remake of Disney’s *Snow White* in 2025, alongside Rachel Zegler and Gal Gadot.

Dujonna Gift — LON

Dujonna Gift is currently starring as New Yorker Robin in Jim Barne and Kit Buchan’s new British musical Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) at the Criterion Theatre in the West End.

Dujonna Gift - Stars on Stage | London Theatre

Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) Tickets

About Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)

Run time

Venue

Categories

Age

Start date

End date

Stars on stage

Sam Tutty

Dujonna Gift

Venue

Criterion Theatre

Directions

Tickets

More shows you may like